What is variable compensation? A complete guide for employers

Variable compensation can feel like a double-edged sword. On the one side, it can motivate team members to push harder and tether your payroll to real business goals or outcomes. On the other, it’s notoriously tricky to design and manage. Get it wrong, and you risk confusing your employees, overspending to reward the wrong kinds of initiative, and undermining morale. 

In this guide, we’ll break down what variable pay is, how it works, and how to leverage it as part of your broader compensation strategy. We’ll cover common plan types, best practices for implementation, and pitfalls to watch out for.

What is variable compensation?

Variable compensation is any form of pay that changes based on performance, results, or progress towards overall company goals. Unlike a fixed salary or hourly wage, it follows outcomes. 

The goal? To tie employee earnings directly to business impact, creating a system where bigger contributions mean bigger paychecks. For most employers, it’s part of a broader compensation management strategy that blends financial stability with performance-driven upsides. 

How does variable compensation work?

Variable compensation comes down to three core components:

1.  The goals you set

2. The metrics you track

3. The timing of the payouts

Employers define objectives and tie them to measurable KPIs. HR and finance teams then use payroll or compensation management software to track performance and calculate what’s owed, with payments typically arriving monthly, quarterly, or at year-end. 

Example: Jordan has a $60,000 base salary, plus 10% on any deal closed. Each time a new customer signs a $20,000 contract, Jordan pockets an extra $2,000 on top of the regular paycheck, usually paid out the following month.

What’s the difference between fixed and variable compensation?

Fixed compensation is the steady paycheck that keeps the lights on and the fridge stocked; variable compensation is what makes your employees double-check the bank app after a good month. Most companies combine the two as part of compensation planning to build a “total compensation” package that balances both security and upside.

Give your employees the full breakdown of their compensation with our free total compensation template. 

Fixed compensation 

Fixed compensation is the reliable part of a paycheck: the base salary or hourly wage that shows up no matter what. It’s how your employees pay the bills without stressing if this month’s pipeline is thin. 

Variable compensation

Variable compensation is generally less predictable; it’s the bonuses, sales commissions, or profit sharing that make paychecks exciting. Close a $100,000 deal and earnings jump. Missed quota? Back to hustling to pay for little extras. It’s designed to keep your team hustling, because the payoff depends on performance.

Business is complex. Payroll shouldn’t be.

See Rippling

Types of variable compensation

Employers have a wide set of tools from which to choose when it comes to variable compensation plans, each with its own strengths, risks, and target audiences. Below are common variable compensation plan examples that demonstrate how they work in practice and the trade-offs you can expect.

Commission

Commission is common in sales, where sales reps earn a percentage of each deal that they close. It’s easy to calculate and strongly tied to results, but it can also encourage short-term thinking.

Example: Jordan earns a 7% commission on every software subscription sold. Closing $100,000 in deals one month adds $7,000 to their paycheck. 

Annual performance bonuses

Annual bonuses reward overall contributions to company performance, often based on revenue, profit, or meeting broader company goals. They’re more flexible than other types of variable compensation, but may feel disconnected from day-to-day performance because they’re paid once a year.

Example: Taylor receives a 10% year-end bonus if the company hits its $50 million revenue target and they meet their own project deadlines. Last year, that meant an extra $8,000 on top of their base salary of $80,000.

Spot bonuses

Spot bonuses are one-time payouts that recognize exceptional effort, like closing a difficult account or pitching in extra time during a busy quarter. They can reward employees and show appreciation immediately, but require a clear structure to avoid the appearance of favoritism.

Example: Morgan lands a tough new client and receives a $1,500 spot bonus, along with other team members who contributed to closing the account.

Profit sharing

Profit sharing distributes a portion of company profits to employees, typically every quarter or every year. This model helps employee incentives on track with business goals, but payouts are unpredictable if profits fluctuate.

Example: Casey gets 3% of Acme Co.’s profits each spring. When profits hit $5 million, that means a $2,500 check. Last year, however, it was only $600.

Stock options or equity grants

Equity-based incentives like stock options are common in startups and public companies targeting long-term growth. They tie employee wealth to company valuation, which can drive commitment, but the benefits can feel distant if the company is years away from liquidity.

Example: Alex receives 2,000 stock options valued at $5 per share. If the company eventually IPOs at $25 per share, the equity will be worth $40,000 before taxes.

Team or department incentives

Instead of rewarding individuals, these plans tie payouts to collective performance, like meeting a project deadline or hitting a team target. They foster collaboration but can frustrate star players if others don’t pull their weight.

Example: Riley’s five-person team earns a $10,000 bonus for finishing a rollout two weeks early. Each member pockets $2,000, even though Riley did the lion’s share of the work.

Goal-based incentives

These plans reward employees for achieving specific objectives beyond sales or profit, such as improving efficiency or completing an internal milestone. They’re flexible and support broader business goals, but take care when defining and measuring goals.

Example: Sam earns a $500 bonus for completing a certification course within six months.

Non-cash variable compensation

Travel, gift cards, and extra vacation days can all count as variable compensation. These can be both cost-effective and personally meaningful, but they might lack the appeal of direct pay. 

Example: Jamie wins a weekend trip valued at $1,200 for surpassing quarterly service goals. It’s a fun perk, but the money in hand would’ve gone towards the mortgage payment.

Why do employers use variable compensation?

For most employers, the draw of variable pay is simple: it’s a direct line between performance and reward. Instead of just paying for time, you pay for results, whether in the form of improved retention, increased profit, or smashed quotas. A variable compensation plan can also give you more leverage over costs while keeping employees hungry for wins.

Drives performance and accountability

Variable pay makes outcomes impossible to ignore. When part of the paycheck hinges on whether or not your team hits their sales targets, for example, it pushes accountability down to the individual level. Employees understand that they need to do more than “look busy”—they need to make an impact.

Aligns individual behavior with company goals

Linking incentive compensation to business goals is one way to turn strategy into daily action. If your focus is on closing deals or protecting margins, you can design a plan that literally pays your employees to produce those outcomes. 

Controls fixed labor costs

Shifting part of your team’s pay into the “variable” column gives you a certain amount of cost flexibility. Instead of carrying all costs as a guaranteed salary, you reserve a portion for performance-driven payouts. That way, labor expenses move with results, which makes them easier to manage in both strong and weak quarters.

Attracts high performers in competitive industries 

In fields like tech or sales, top talent expects more than just a healthy base salary. Sales commissions, bonuses, and other variable rewards tell ambitious candidates that delivering can impact their bank account as much as your bottom line.

Pros and cons of variable compensation

A variable compensation plan done right sends a strong message about your broader compensation philosophy: what matters to your business and how you reward team members who support those goals. It also sharpens team focus and keeps compensation costs adaptable. Done poorly, it can lead to stress, bad habits, and headaches for your payroll and finance pros. 

Advantages of variable compensation

The upsides of variable comp? They’re pretty easy to see. When structured well, incentives push your team to go for more while giving you space to maneuver in your compensation strategy.

• Motivates high performance. When employees see their paycheck growing alongside output, they don’t need pep talks. Hitting sales targets, driving profit, or beating quota comes with a built-in reward.

• Aligns employee goals with company objectives. Tying incentive pay to things like revenue growth or retention can help keep everyone rowing in the same direction. 

• Helps attract high-performing talent. High achievers often look for upsides beyond base salary. A total compensation package that includes bonuses or sales commissions tells top performers they’ll be paid handsomely—for generating results.

• Adds flexibility to total compensation budgets. Fixed pay is predictable, but rigid. Variable pay shifts some of those costs into the “only if we win” column and gives you breathing room in lean quarters.

Disadvantages of variable compensation

Then again, the drawbacks are just as real. Without careful design and implementation, a system intended to improve team morale and outcomes can become a source of anxiety, backstabbing, and wasted cash.

• Income unpredictability for employees. Very few people can plan a mortgage around a commission that swings from month to month. Income dips can make it harder for employees to feel financially secure, even when their annual earnings look solid. 

• Can create unhealthy competition. A sloppy commission plan turns teammates into rivals. When your sales reps start fighting for leads and cutting one another out, you know you’re rewarding the wrong behaviors.

• May lead to short-term thinking. When you tie pay too tightly to quick wins, some employees will end up chasing the fastest path to a payout, regardless of whether that supports long-term company goals.

• Complex to manage and administer. Someone needs to take responsibility for calculating, tracking, and reporting each and every payout for tax purposes. Without strong systems that go beyond spreadsheets, you’re navigating a compliance minefield.

Fully customizable payroll software

See Rippling

Challenges of managing variable compensation

Conceptually, variable compensation plans look like a win-win: employees push harder, and the business reaps the rewards. In practice, they can be tricky to get right. The same plan that lights a fire under one group can lead to facepalms from another, and the administrative overhead can drown your HR and finance pros without the right systems in place. 

Complexity of designing fair plans

Getting a compensation strategy right is harder than it looks, and striking the right balance is a challenge for any employer. Overly simple models risk ignoring nuances in roles or different levels of effort, while more complicated versions can confuse employees and lead to disputes. 

Risk of demotivation if goals are unrealistic

Set sales targets too high, and people give up before they even start. Set them too low, and payouts stop feeling like real rewards. The key? Find targets that stretch your team just enough to drive effort without feeling hopelessly out of reach.

Administrative burden

Tracking commissions, bonuses, and other payouts can become a heavy lift for your HR and finance teams. (96.6% of HR leaders already report spending more than a quarter of their time on admin.) Without automation, the manual work of calculating earnings, checking for errors, and keeping up with variable payment structures eats into valuable time for strategic work.

Compliance and tax reporting issues

The IRS treats variable compensation as taxable, but rules on withholding aren’t always straightforward. Missteps around supplemental wage rates or payroll taxes can create compliance risks, and employers need accurate reporting to protect both the business and employees from unpleasant conversations around tax time.

Best practices for implementing a variable compensation plan

Rolling out a variable compensation plan takes more than choosing the right incentives. You need a clear compensation strategy that meshes employee motivation with company goals, and for that to happen, you need fairness, transparency, and clear alignment between pay and performance. By setting realistic expectations and reviewing outcomes over time, you can build a system that both rewards employees and strengthens your business.

1. Define measurable and realistic goals

Begin by tying your plan to achievable business targets. Goals that require superhuman feats can discourage employees from even trying, while vague targets make it hard to measure success and breed expensive misunderstandings (or resentment). Using clear KPIs helps ensure that payouts reflect genuine contributions to the business.

2. Align pay with business outcomes

If the compensation strategy doesn’t support defined company goals, you may end up paying for effort that doesn’t move the needle. Link incentive pay to outcomes like revenue, profit, or retention so people see exactly how their work drives results.

3. Use clear, transparent plans

Confusion is the quickest way to undermine a variable compensation plan. Spell out the criteria, from quotas to payouts, so sales teams and other employees understand the “rules of the game.” Transparency fosters trust and prevents the grumbling that comes with fuzzy, shifting standards.

4. Monitor and adjust regularly

No commission plan stays perfectly aligned with your business forever. In fact, if you’re doing it right, the team should outgrow the existing model as business targets get met. As markets change, review the plan and make adjustments before it loses impact. A regular check-in keeps variable pay tied to what your business needs now.

5. Integrate with performance management tools

Connecting your variable comp framework to performance reviews gives you a more complete picture of both achievements and rewards. It also simplifies tracking. Managers can spot patterns, and employees see exactly how their results translate into earnings.

Simplify variable compensation management with Rippling

Managing a variable compensation plan only works if payroll can keep up with the complexity: different pay rates, commissions, and bonuses all need to be tracked and taxed correctly. Enter Rippling. 

Rippling offers full-service payroll built on top of a single source of truth for employee data. That means your employee data isn’t tied to one specific app—it’s the same across payroll, time and attendance, onboarding, performance management, and any other apps you use within our unified platform. 

That means Rippling’s natively built payroll software offers a seamless data pipeline that consolidates all your payroll functions on a single platform for a globally compliant pay run.  Combined with Rippling’s suite of benefits management and time and attendance tools, it transforms operations for a 42% efficiency lift across payroll, HR, and finance.

With Rippling, you can: 

• Pay employees and contractors on the same platform

• Manage time and attendance natively 

• Run unlimited off-cycle pay runs at no extra cost 

• Set up multiple pay schedules, pay rates, and pay types in just a few clicks 

• Add recurring reimbursements (like cell phone payments, gym memberships, etc.) that are automatically paid out every pay period, monthly, or at whatever interval you choose

• Automatically calculate prorated pay runs for new or promoted employees 

• Make changes after submitting payroll

Variable compensation FAQs

What is an example of variable compensation?

A sales commission plan, where a salesperson earns a percentage of every deal closed,  is a common example of variable compensation. Other examples include year-end bonuses, quarterly profit-sharing, or stock options as part of a broader compensation package. These forms of pay aren’t guaranteed like a base salary; they depend on the employee or the organization achieving specific outcomes. 

How do you create a variable pay plan?

To create a variable pay plan, start by defining clear business objectives and linking them to measurable performance metrics for your team. Choosing the right mix of incentives, like bonuses, sales commissions, and profit sharing, keeps your compensation plan aligned with solid financial management and actual results. From there, set key performance indicators and establish transparent criteria so employees know exactly how their paychecks connect to results. A well-structured plan motivates individual performance while keeping rewards tied to overall organizational progress.

Is variable compensation taxable?

Yes, variable compensation is taxable. The IRS classifies items like bonuses, commissions, and other incentive pay as supplemental wages. Employers either combine them with regular salary and withhold taxes at the applicable rate (the aggregate method) or apply the flat supplemental rate of 22%. In both cases, employees also pay Social Security and Medicare taxes.

What's the difference between a bonus and incentive pay?

The difference between a bonus and incentive pay lies in timing and purpose. A bonus is typically a one-time reward employees receive after the fact that recognizes strong personal performance or company results. Incentive pay, on the other hand, is structured in advance and tied to specific metrics you, as the employer, want to reach. It sets clear expectations up front and links earnings to how well team members meet the established targets.

What is variable pay?

Variable pay is the part of a paycheck that isn’t fixed. Instead of being guaranteed, like base salary, it’s typically tied to how well your employee performs and depends on whether they close deals, hit targets, or push the company towards specific goals. Examples include bonuses, commissions, and even profit sharing. In other words, it’s an incentive-driven way to reward results. The better the team or the company does, the more the employee earns.

This blog is based on information available to Rippling as of August 22, 2025.